A Yellow Aster, Volume 2 (of 3)

Key themes

Social Expectation vs. Individual Desire

This theme is central to Volume 2, explored through Sir Humphrey Strange's struggle to reconcile his personal inclinations and desires with the immense societal pressures and responsibilities that accompany his newly inherited wealth and status. The novel highlights the rigid class structures and expectations of late Victorian society, particularly concerning proper conduct, marriage, and legacy, which often conflict with the protagonist's yearning for authentic self-expression and love.

Identity and Self-Discovery

The novel deeply explores the theme of identity, particularly how it is shaped by external circumstances versus internal conviction. Sir Humphrey Strange's sudden transformation in status forces him into a profound journey of self-discovery. He grapples with who he is meant to be as 'Sir Humphrey' versus the person he truly feels himself to be, questioning whether wealth and title define a man or merely adorn him. His feelings of inadequacy underscore this struggle for an authentic self.

The Nature of Love and Duty

This theme examines the complexities of romantic relationships within the context of societal obligations and personal morality. Sir Humphrey finds himself caught between the potential for a duty-bound, socially appropriate match (perhaps with Lady Mary, or someone similar) and a passionate, possibly unconventional attraction to Gwen Waring. The novel delves into whether true love can flourish under the weight of duty, or if duty itself can be a form of love, albeit less fervent.

Worth discussing

How does Sir Humphrey Strange's initial reaction to his inheritance reflect or challenge Victorian attitudes towards wealth and responsibility?